Typical Earthing Resistance Value

  • The resistance offered by the earth electrode to the flow of current into the ground is known as the earth resistance or resistance to earth.
  • Ideally a ground resistance should be of zero ohms but It is always greater than Zero .System ground resistances can be reduce by the use of a number of individual electrodes connected together.
  • Total earthing resistance is the sum of the resistance of earth lead wires, Contact resistance between the surface of the earth electrode and the soil and The resistance of the body of the soil surrounding the earth electrode.
  • The value of earthing resistance varies on the Type of Soil, Soil characteristic, soil resistivity and the climatic condition. Moisture content in soil plays a vital role in the soil resistivity. value of individual earthing pit resistance is not so important. Different codes specifies the required value of earthing system.
  • Electrical Systems can work with earth resistance of 20 ohms, though generally 10 ohms is the specified Maximum limit.
  • But communication systems need very stringent limit, typically one ohm. This is because the higher the ground resistance, higher would be noise interference in the systems.

USAID

a) Power stations (generating station)

0.5 ohms

b) EHT Sub-station

1.0 ohms

c) 33 KV Stations

2.0 ohms

d) D/t Structure

5.0 ohms

e) Tower Foot resistance

10.0 ohms

IEEE STANDARD 142

Chapter: 4.1.3 , page 164
For industrial plant substations and buildings and large commercial installations.

1Ω to 5 Ω

Resistances of less than 1 ohm may be obtained using a number of individual electrodes connected together. Such a low resistance is only required for large substations, transmission lines, or generating stations.

National Electric code (NEC) 2011, (IS SP30 Chapter 14 -India)

Chapter: 3.0.9
unless otherwise specified ,It is recommended that the value of any earth system resistance shall not be more than

IS 3043 (India)

Chapter: 22.2.3
The continuity resistance of the earth return path through the earth grid should be maintained as low as possible and in no case greater than

This applicable for main earth grid connected with the transformer/return path

Oil Industry Safety Directorate Government of India (OISD STANDARD – 137)

Chapter: (7. ii. b) Allowable earth-Resistance Values
Allowable earth-Resistance Values The resistance value of an earthing system to general mass of the earth should not exceed.
For electrical systems and metallic structures.

4Ω

For storage tanks.

7Ω

for main earth grid, and bonding connections between joints in pipelines and associated facilities.

1Ω

for each electrode to the general mass of the earth

2Ω

IS 2309 (india) / BS 7430:1998

Clause:12.3.1 Page 32,Resistance to Earth
Lightning arrestors ground resistance for  Protection of buildings and allied structures is

10Ω

An earth electrode should be connected to each down conductor. Each of these earths should have a resistance not exceeding the product given by 10 a multiplied by the number of earth electrodes to be provided.
The whole of the lightning protective system, including any ring earth, should have a combined resistance to earth not exceeding 10 Ω without taking account of any bonding.
If the value obtained for the whole of the lightning protective systems exceeds 10 Ω, a reduction can be achieved by extending or adding to the electrodes or by interconnecting the individual earth terminations of the down conductors by a conductor installed below ground, sometimes referred to as a ring conductor

IS 2689:1989

Table 4 page 28 (Reaffirmed March 2010)
Lightning arrestors ground resistance for Protection  of buildings and allied structures is

10Ω

NEC 250.56

Clause: 250.53 Grounding Electrode System Installation.
The maximum resistance for a single electrode consisting of a rod, pipe, or plate.

25Ω

If a higher resistance is obtained for a single electrode, a second electrode of any of the types specified in the NEC is required.
This should not be interpreted to mean that 25 ohm is a satisfactory resistance value for a grounding system.

IEEE Std 80-2000 (Revision of IEEE Std 80-1986)

the evaluation of ground resistance for the most transmission and other large substations, the ground resistance is usually about

1Ω or less

In smaller distribution substations, the usually acceptable range is

1Ω to 5Ω

NFC 17-102, July 1995

that the resistance value measured using conventional equipment should be

1Ω or less

This resistance should be measured on the earthing termination insulated from any other conductive component.

IEC 62305-1

edition 2.0 – 2010-12
the conventional earthing impedance related to the earth termination system is (*for the soil resistivity less than or equal to 100 Ω)

4 Ω

Ministry of Railways- Government of India

 
The acceptable Earth Resistance at earth MEEB bus bar shall not be more than

1Ω

For achieving this value more than one earth pits can be installed if necessary depending upon the soil resistivity. In places where space is not available to provide parallel earth pits then longer earth rods may be provided.
The longer earth rods thus provided should be in multiples of three meters.
The combined resistance of the earthing system shall be not more than the following values
Traction substation

0.5Ω

Switching station

2Ω

Booster transformer station

10Ω

Auxiliary transformer station

10Ω

Maximum values of earth resistances specified for earthing of Signaling and Telecommunication equipment’s are as under
Telegraph and Block Instrument using earth return circuit 10 Ω
Earths for surge arrestors/ lightening dischargers

10Ω

Earthing of Signalling equipment

10Ω

Earthing of signalling cable screen in AC electrified areas

10Ω

Earthing of Telephone Exchange

Earthing of aluminum sheathed telecom cable in AC electrified area

Earthing of equipment in VF repeater stations and cable huts.

Axle counter cable screened in AC electrified area

Electronic Interlocking installation

Integrated Power Supply System & its individual modules

Digital Axle Counter EJB and its apparatus case connected to same earth All cable armors connected to same earth.

Reset box of Digital Axle Counter connected to earth (indoor) near SM’s Room.

Railway Vikas Nigam Limited

RVNL/Elect/GS/11
The earth continuity test of metallic envelopes shall be done for electrical continuity. Electrical resistance of the same, along with the earthing lead, excluding any added resistance of earth leakage circuit breaker, measured from the connection with the earth electrode to any point in the earth conductor in the completed installation, shall not exceed

No earth electrode shall have resistance greater than

In rocky soil, the resistance may be up to

Locations having more than one electrode shall be connected in parallel to reduce the resistance.

MANUAL OF STANDARDS & SPECIFICATIONS FOR RAILWAY ELECTRIFICATION

RDSO/SPN/197/2008
Equipment’s with solid state components which are more susceptible to damage due to surges, transients and over voltages being encountered in the system due to lightning, sub-station switching such as Electronic Interlocking, Integrated Power supply equipment, Digital Axle counter, Data logger etc. shall Value of earth resistance shall not be more than

For conventional signaling equipment’s the earth resistance shall not be more than

10Ω

DHASHIN HARYANA BIJALI VITRAN NIGAM (DHBVN)

Specification no CSC-140 / DH/UH/P&D
Hose hold Earthing (3KA)

<8Ω

Commercial / Industrial Buildings (5KA)

<2Ω

Transformer / LT Line Earthing  (15KA)

1Ω to 2Ω

Transformer / Substation /HT Line ,HT Switchgear (40KA)

<1Ω

Lighting Arrester /Extra High Current appliances (50KA)

<1Ω

UPS / Data center / ATM

<0.5 Ω

*Earthing may be Single or Multiple Electrode.

Earthing Value

Earthing Condition Earthing Value
Best

0.1Ω to 2Ω

Good

2.1Ω to 5Ω

Need to be Maintenance

5.1Ω to 10Ω

Need to be Replacement

>10Ω

Difference between Fault Current and Short Circuit Current

Introduction:

  • There is a difference between “Fault Current” and “Short Circuit Current” in electrical system. Both parameters are important while selecting an Equipment or designing a Network, however both terms are misled in Electrical engineering.
  • In very simple language “Short” means less (shortest distance, time or circuit), Short circuit Fault means least resistance or no resistance in circuit and Current is high due to less resistance. This high current convert into heat energy. The opposite of a short circuit is an “open circuit”, which is an infinite resistance between two nodes.
  • While Fault means wrong. Fault Current means Current pass in to wrong path.

What is Fault Current

  • A fault current is a current which takes the wrong path instead of using the normal conducting path during Fault condition.
  • Under normal condition, the electric equipment operate at normal voltage and current ratings. Once the fault occurs in a circuit or device, voltage and current value deviates from their nominal Value. This may be high or Low Values.
  • The fault may be occurred due to insulation failures, Wrong Connection or conducting path failures, which further convert in Open Circuit, Short Circuit and Ground Fault.
  • A fault current can either current being more or less than the normal rated current.
  • In Three phase power system, there are basically three types of Fault Current.
  • Open Circuit Faults
  • Short Circuit Faults (L-L / L-L-L)
  • Ground Circuit Faults (L-G / L-L-L-G)

What is Short Circuit Current:

  • When a two or more conductors of differential potential comes to contact with each other (one phase comes in contact with other Phase, Neutral or Earth) gives the electricity to a path of less resistance hence a large current flow in the un-faulted phases, such current is called the short circuit current.
  • When Short circuit occurs, current returns to its source without passing to the load. It caused zero or very little resistance and No Voltage drop in that circuit.
  • This Current will be the maximum that the source can deliver for a very small time before the protection device operates. The current is limited only by the resistance of the rest of the circuit.
  • We know that V (Voltage) =I (current) x R (resistance of Circuit).
  • When short circuit occur, resistance is very small and can be considered as negligible. We can consider R=0. This means I = V/0, which means infinite current will Flow so the conductor must have the capacity to allow this huge current to flow. In most of the cases breakdown happens.
  • The resistance when short circuit occur is very small and can be considered as negligible. We can consider R=0.
  • This means V=Ix0, which means Voltage at Short circuit is very Less.
  • V(drop)=0 and current(I)=infinite
  • Short circuit gives thousands time larger Current than the normal current and Zero Voltage at Fault Point. This will produce more heat and result in burns and fires.
  • Short circuit faults are also called as Shunt faults.
  • Causes:
  • Over Loading of Equipment: Overloading of equipment and insulation failure due to lighting surges and mechanical damage.
  • Loose Connections:Due to Loose Connections, Sometimes Neutral and Phase wires to touch.
  • Faulty or Wrong Connections: Wrong Connections make Short circuit in Circuit.
  • Failure / Ageing of Insulation:Old or damaged insulation makes neutral and Phase wires to touch, which can cause a short circuit. Punctures in Insulation can damage insulation and makes short circuit.
  • Harmful Effects:
  • The short-circuit produces the arc that causes the major damage of equipment such as transformers and circuit breakers.
  • The short circuit causes a heavy current in the power system which produces excessive heat and hence results in fire or explosion.
  • The short circuit affects the stability of the network which disturbs the continuity of the supply.
  • The operating voltages of the system can go below or above their acceptance values that creates harmful effect to the service rendered by the power system.

Open Circuit Faults:

  • Open Circuit Faults occur due to the Failure / Open of one or more Phase Conductors in Circuit.
  • In Open Circuit Fault, Current cannot flow hence Current is Zero and Voltage become Infinite.
  • V(drop)=infinite and current(I)=0
  • Open circuit faults are also called as series faults. These are unsymmetrical or unbalanced type of faults except three phase open fault.
  • Causes:
  • Broken Conductor, Failure of Conductor Joints and malfunctioning of circuit breaker in one or more phases.
  • Harmful Effects:
  • Abnormal operation of the system.
  • Danger to the Human and Animals.
  • Exceeding the voltages beyond normal values in certain parts of the network, which leads to insulation failures and developing of short circuit faults.

Difference between Fault Current and Short Circuit Current:

Circuit Resistance:

  • A short circuit has zero resistance between two Wires / Circuits / Systems, on the other hand a Fault current has a resistance that draws current. The amount of resistance decides how much current is drawn and is usually caused by a breakdown in the insulation of a system.

Amount of Current:

  • Fault Current: it is the current exceeding the equipment current rating e.g. motor rated 25A, then more than this will be the fault current.
  • Short Circuit current: it is the maximum current which can flow when the equipment is short circuited & it can withstand. above this the current will damage the equipment.
  • Fault current is the current that flows during an Open Circuit or Short Circuit Fault condition so each time it is not necessary that Fault Current is a Short Circuit Current (It may be Open Circuit Fault).
  • A short-circuit current will flow when there is short-circuit in the system, and it will represent the highest possible fault current that a system can experience.
  • Therefore, a fault current can be less that the short-circuit current, and a short-circuit current will represent the highest fault current in the system.
  • A fault current can either current being more or less than the normal current while Short Circuit Current is higher than Normal Current.

  • A Fault Current is not necessary a short circuit Current but Short Circuit Current is always a Fault Current.

Comparison of Fault Current -Short Circuit Current

Basis For Comparison Fault Current (Open Circuit Fault) Short Circuit Fault Overload
Meaning In the Open circuit the voltage at the fault point is high up to infinite and current is zero through the faulty point of the network. In the short circuit the voltage at the fault point decreases to zero and current of irregular high value flow through the faulty point of the network. The overload means that load greater than the desired value have been imposed on the system.
Resistance High Zero
Current Zero High Low as compared to short circuit.
Voltage High Zero The voltage becomes low, but cannot be zero.
Occur It occurs when the neutral and live wire Break or Open. It occurs when the neutral and live wire touch each other. It occurs when a large number of devices are joint in a single socket.

Importance of Fault Current and Short circuit Current for designing of System or Panel.

  • The safety of the system is decided by short-circuit current rating (SCCR) of the Equipment with the reference of the available fault current where the Equipment is installed. 
  • The short circuit current rating gives a baseline for the fault current that an equipment can withstand for a specific amount of time, or until it clears the circuit with opening of a circuit breaker.
  • The short circuit current rating of a panel is the amount of energy, usually expressed as a value in kilo-Amperes (kA), that the panel can handle without causing fire, a shock hazard, or explosive danger.
  • In equipment with higher short-circuit current ratings compared to Fault Current is not an issue.
  • The available fault current of panel can be decided by the size of the upstream transformer, size of the electrical conductors / Cables up to the Equipment.
  • If the System Fault Current at the Location is 20KA to 50KA and if we use Equipment having short circuit current of 5KA to 10KA may cause damages of equipment or network in fault condition.
  • If the System Fault Current at the Location is 5KA to 10KA and if we use Equipment having short circuit current of 65KA to 100KA will not create any issue but it will unnecessarily increase the price of equipment hence short circuit level of the equipment is not too much high with respect of fault current.
  • We have to ensure that the Short Circuit Current is equal or more than Fault Current available at the point of Equipment.